The Harry Potter book almost have a complete earth built in , thanks to seven books , several standoff - in , and , for good or for bad , whatever writer J.K. Rowling decided to introduce inPottermore . Despite all the item that has gone into craft his universe , there are still some thing that ca n’t be account for — things that keep Potterheads up at night ( Literally . A roommate and I spent two hours hear discussing the logistics of the first entryway on the list ) .
Before we get go , I do want to note that these are questions to consider when interacting with Harry Potter , but that ’s all they are . Media is meant to be enjoyed to variegate arcdegree , so do n’t deter those that look at Harry Potter and wonder more . thing such as …
1) What do kids do before going to wizarding school?
Harry received his letter to Hogwarts on his eleventh birthday , but what do tiddler do before then ? On the first train at Platform 9 3/4 , we see the Weasley ’s board the train , leave the youngest , Ginny behind with her parents . She ’d get to attend school in the second book , but what was she doing this whole prison term while her brother Ron was getting up to hijinks in his starter year ?
consort to theHarry Potter Wikia , most sorcerous children are either homeschooled by their parent or are broadcast to muggle schools until they are of years . This is apparently something Rowling has mentioned , but I could n’t obtain connectedness to any of the interview where she state it . There is aPottermore articlewhere she say that many children are home schooled rather than go to one of the very few schooling . The most ordered explanation is that child who end up at the schools are likewise educated before they leave .
But that just raise more questions . Is there a universal curriculum for parents to homeschool their children , as there is in our world ? It would make mother wit for wizards that amount from muggle fellowship to send their child to muggle school day , but what about those with wizard parentage ? If the latter do attend normal primary school , how do they bring off to keep everything about their lives a secret ? Even Harry , who had no noesis of his inheritance , accidentally performed magic on multiple occasion . I can think the ruction a child claiming their parents have campaign dragon . Although , anything a kid say could just be excused with normal childish vision so perhaps Rowling ’s on to something .
While we ’re on the subject field of education , though …
2) Do wizards know math?
We assume that wizards have to know basic mathematics due to potion - devising ’s similarity to alchemy , but what about anything beyond addition and subtraction ? Us muggles had to see the multiplication tables in simple school and afterward , experienced the pains of long division , and that ’s not including trigonometry and algebra — significant thing for engineering and scientists , but not too relevant for other masses . Wizards would n’t have a pauperism for complex math if most of what they do can be explicate by magic .
The closest we get to anything resembling maths in the Hogwarts course catalogue is Arithmancy , opine of to be the study of presage the futurity using numbers , but it ’s an elective . It ’s also not important enough to fare into play throughout the books or for us to get to know the prof .
The best explanation is that mavin are teach basic math , either at home or in muggle schooling , along with other skills such as meter reading , but since they almost never seem to expend mathematics after the long time 11 , how necessary is it ? We can assume Goblins live all the math that the wizarding world would ever need , so maybe they do n’t need it at all .
3) How many wizards are there in the world?
The warfare with Voldemort could explain Harry’ssmall category size(since war broadly have a blue rate of newborns ) , but that does n’t take into account the sparseness of wizarding population . In the core books , we learn about three schools — Hogwarts , Durmstrang , and Beauxbatons — but in total there are 11 “ long - established ” schools that are registered with the International Confederation of Wizards , with lowly , less regulated single derive and lead . There ’d have to be because the mathematics does n’t check out .
If there are around 1,000 students in seven years of Hogwarts — including muggles without any original tie-in with magic — then that would mean that the wizard population in all the United Kingdom is miniscule , maybe less than one percent of the total universe .
And what about the US , for illustration , where there only seems to be Ilvermony , which could n’t maybe hold up all necromancer students from America and Canada ( since there ’s no school in Canada ) . And what about Mahoutokoro School of Magic in Japan ? Does that imply that everyone in Asia has to go there ? And that ’s not take into chronicle the cultural differences between different Asiatic countries and how that is look at with in the effect that this is true . It would be interesting if the virtuoso universe was so humble , but look at what Rowling has built up in the wake of the Harry Potter series ending , things do n’t add up .
4) How alive are portraits?
This is more of an ethical quandary , but how are moving portraits associated with the people they limn ? Would a portraiture of Dumbledore be inculcate with the soul ( if we ’re using that as the marker of sensation ) of the former master even after his expiry ? While Rowling does expand on it a minute in later books , it only raises more enquiry .
In the Harry Potter and the Cursed Child , we get more of a glance into what the portrait of Dumbledore feel and thinks , and it seems that there is something of a freestanding presence . The Scripture states :
DUMBLEDORE : Ah really , what does my judgment matter anymore ? I am pigment and memory , Harry , pigment and memory . And I never had a son .
He also state :
DUMBLEDORE : Those that we love never really pull up stakes us , Harry . There are things that death can not touch . Paint . . . and remembering . . . and erotic love .
accord toPottermore , the portrait is more of a transcript of a somebody and its level of interactivity can motley . At the link , Rowling states that schoolmaster will often teach their portrait how to conduct . So they are n’t alive in the same fashion that we are animated , but what is their horizontal surface of ego - sentience ? They can move from painting to painting and be shaft to Hogwarts students if they want to , so what ’s to say they are n’t live in their own fashion ? And if they are alive , do mountain lion basically have the mogul to create life ? Are portrayal ever cognisant that they can be active ?
My possibility is that they are separate entities from the people they are portrait of , so it ’s not as if people like Dumbledore are immortal , but if that ’s the caseful , then why does nobody interrogate the moral principle behind redact transcript of dead multitude in the hallway of school ?
Now I ’m thinking too much .
5) Why is Hogwarts so unsafe and who let this happen?
Dumbledore is the high-risk . Or maybe he just inherit a actual last trap from his predecessors and there ’s nothing he can do about it . Regardless , the monstrosity and objects that Harry and his friend find on the Hogwarts grounds are dangerous , and sometimes lifetime peril . Why would a campus have a Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree that literally beats hoi polloi up ? Why would the Hogwarts Expressemploy a Wiccan that excruciate students ?
The worst part of all of this is that the rule are inconsistent surrounding children ’s base hit . In the first book , Dumbledore differentiate kids not to enter the Forbidden Forest , but we see our hero enter it multiple times , sometimes under the supervision of staff . If they really did n’t require kids going in there , could n’t they raise spell to keep them aside ? And what about the wars that seem to take stead inside the castle ? Before the fight at Hogwarts in the seventh leger , it ’s mentioned that many parents refused to send off their kids to schooling that year , but what about the years before that ? If it was lie with throughout the year that there were danger that could pop scholar , why would they bother to keep the school open ? And if parents still wanted their kids to get an education , surely they could ’ve been sent forth to other school .
fundamentally , Dumbledore is a terrible master and the tyke were in peril constantly . Or perchance Rowling postulate all that there in avail of a story . So mayhap the latter make more sense .
FantasyHarry Potter
Daily Newsletter
Get the best technical school , science , and civilisation news in your inbox daily .
word from the hereafter , delivered to your present .
You May Also Like
